Jump to content
  • Knives Out For Robinson Under The Blood Moon


    The Western Sydney Wanderers faced the Wellington Phoenix at home at the Western Sydney Stadium with their finals hopes clinging by a thread, a thread that might as well have been severed following a 2-1 loss.

    With only three games left in the regular season the two sides came into the game locked on 31 points each in 8th & 9th place, with Wellington's 5 goal difference advantage putting them ahead of the home side. With the last finals place being 5 points away a loss for either team while not mathematically fatal to their chances, would make those chances slim to none. Carl Robinson deployed Keanu Baccus in the attacking midfield role in place of James Troisi, while Mitch Duke was playing his last game for the Wanderers in his loan stint due to his call up for the Australian National team's World Cup Qualifiers that begin on the 4th of June.

    The Wanderers had the run of the opening stages, with Baccus' move forward working well as he found open space between the lines and the defenders. He had a cutback blocked and shortly after Mitch Duke had a tough chance from his head after a Ziggy Gordon cross into the middle of the penalty area. Duke then gave away a foul at the far post from a Tate Russell cross that Oli Sail had covered in any case.

    Reno Piscopo took a knock in the 10th mintue, with Ziggy Gordon ensuring that the winger wasn't getting around him, he fell to the turf awkwardly and spent several minutes recieving treatment. Gordon escaped a yellow card as the ball was already heading out for a throw in when the foul took place. Cam Devlin took a shot from long range after a clearance, his swiping right foot sliced the ball up and over the crossbar. Piscopo went down once again in the 13th minute, a slight nudge in the back appeared to worsen the shoulder injury from the Gordon tackle, perhaps indicating a break or dislocation and he was replaced by ex-Wanderer Jaushua Sotirio. 

    The Wanderers two curses this season, conceding from set pieces and going behind early once again reared their ugly head. From a 25th minute corner the ball fell at the near post, Graham Dorrans could only managed to knock the ball onto his own crossbar, it fell at the back post for David Ball and he couldn't miss at closer than point blank fange.

    It didn't take long for the Wanderers to find the back of the net. Their own corner was hit by Mark Natta twice, then Thomas Aquilina before rebounding a 4th time to Bruce Kamau and he fired through a sea of legs. After a short VAR review asking if Sail had his vision impeded by an offside McGowan the goal was allowed to stand, bringing the game back level at 1-1. A 37th minute free kick against Ziggy Gordon gave Clayton Lewis a chance, he lined up a 25 yard strike, curling it over the wall, beating Margush but not the far post.

    The set piece failures rose again to help Wellington to regain the lead. With Margush blocked off by David Ball he was stuck in no-man's land, and Ziggy Gordon got a shove in the back that allowed Tomer Hemed nod the ball hom from 3 yards out. The VAR didn't concern itself with the push in the back or the block and Wellington had the lead 2-1.

    Minutes before half-time the Wanderers should have won a penalty from a set piece as Ziggy Gordon was rugby tackled in the box and taken to ground. Kurt Ams decided it wasn't a penalty in the live action and VAR apparently ignored the incident with play continuing until the break.

    The Wanderers kicked off for the second half, immediately lost the ball and allowed Sotirio to take advantage of a fall from Ziggy Gordon and his shot required a good save from Margush to keep the scoreline 2-1. Tim Payne nearly scored his first ever A-League goal with a flashing near post header that was tipped over for another one, which fell to Devlin and forced another jumping save out of Margush. The 54th minute it was Bruce Kamau having a chance, when a Dorarns free kick was blocked by the wall, Aquilina lofted the ball back into the mixer, Kamau reacted quickest but his stabbed foot shot went straight at the Wellington keeper.

    Robinson reacted to the deficit with one of his trademark 60th minute substitutions, taking off the Wanderers top goalscorer Bruce Kamau to bring on Bruce Kamau. Ziggy Gordon continued his wild night with an awful late challenge on Sotirio, he flew in, missed the ball and collected Sotirio flush on the ankle. Earlier in the life of the VAR that foul would have likely seen an upgrade from his yellow card to a straight red but he remained on the pitch.

    Ibini had his first shot of the game in the 66th minute, with Duke pouncing on a mishit pass from Devlin and launching a lightning attack that Ibini finished with a shot that blazed well over the bar. Jordon Mutch & Scott McDonald lined up to replace Steven Ugarkovic, after his final action, a long range free kick that went wide. Ziggy Gordon did end up leaving the game early but not through what would have been a deserved red card. McDonald should have equalised with his first touch of the game, the ball falling for Mutch, his shot outside the box was soft but only pushed away by Sail into the feet of the newly arrived striker but he scooped it over the bar when everyone expected it to burst the roof of the net. Nicolai Muller came on for Baccus in the 79th minute. 

    The Wanderers threw everyone forward as the game moved into the four minutes of stoppage time, the big chance fell inside the 6 yard box to Tate Russell after a rebound from Sotirio, he smashed the ball but Payne threw out a boot and blocked the shot. Even if the Wanderers pulled off two wins in the last games of the season it would still take a minor miracle to make the Top 6 with a bevy of results having to go their way. Once again in the post-game press conference Robinson elected to blame the players for their poor defending rather than take responsibility for not having fixed the glaring issue after a season in charge. It remains to be seen if the club ownership will pull the trigger on another one season sacking but it is clear the patience of the supporters has already run out, the blood moon in the sky at full time perhaps a portent for the end of Robinson's tenure as the Wanderers coach.

    The Wanderers next match is against Brisbane Roar on Sunday May 30th at Parramatta with kick-off at 4:05PM.


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Another wasted season of hope,despair,hope,then reality hits and we're crap as usual.

    Going to be another interesting off season. Whether Robinson is manager or not it will be different squad. We're going to lose a few ( Kamau,Muller Duke Mutch McDonald ). 

    Edited by sonar
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Time for Carl Robinson to go

    We stole him from Newcastle only to end up in the same position as the Jets (out of finals and into a FFA Cup playoff)

    Had a good time at the stadium but the poor form really stuffs up my socialising as so many fans won't come and watch (and rightly so)

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Another year blown, the only enjoyable thing is the gallows humour and the odds on the coach being sacked. 
    On the positive side, doesn’t next season start in October? Yay we can do it all again!

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The empty seats said as much as the performance on the pitch, the fans have finally had enough.

    The stadium will be dead and empty for the dead rubber this weekend.

    All we need now is an email to the fans from Paul ‘mark my words’ Lederer and it will be complete.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    My favourite part was when CR FINALLY decides to sub off a CB for for it CM it seemed we were actually going to go from 5atb to 4atb....Nope, keeping 5atb and playing a CM out of position at CB. What a perfect decision when your chasing a game and season. May aswell also bring off your leading goal scorer while you're at it....oh hang on.

    I've not been an advocate for the coach carousel WSW has had of late and more than 1 who has been sacked was done so prematurely in my opinion. CR has no excuse. He built this squad and on paper it is probably the best in the league. His tactical decisions, formation choice, substitution choices, squad selection and inability to sort out the issues we have had from set pieces all season all points to one choice. Get out Carl Robinson. JT and Lederer can f#ck off too.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    7 minutes ago, MathyouWSW said:

    Taking Kamau off for Ibini (despite him having a good game) was the nail in the coffin.

    I was curious about that as well. If he was going to make a swap like that, I would have made it Duke off, not Kamau.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Season was over when we lost to Victory. Even if mathematically we still had a chance we did not deserve playing in the finals.

    CR needs to go, on paper we had the best squad and we didn't even make the finals. His team selections, formations and subs is what caused this. The worst part that he was not willing to change the losing formula.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Well that was a waste of an evening. Freezing my arse off watching an insipid effort from a bunch of mainly 2nd rate footballers way past their prime. The team selection, formation and substitutions demonstrate that CR does not have the nous to coach a successful team in the A-League. The small crowd and lack of atmosphere show what the fans think of the team and their performance. I even had to put up with two Wellington supporters who decided to sit in front of me (so much for covid and sitting in your allocated seat!). One of them even had the nerve to jump up and wave his bloody flag for 5 minutes when they scored until I told him to sit down and stop waving his flag as he was annoying me!

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Carl wasn't happy when being intervied after the game on Fox.

    He said he needs to make changes, and if players don't want to be here, they can **** off.

    We played well tonight but yet again, we cannot finish. So frustrating.

     

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    3 minutes ago, Wanderboy said:

    Carl wasn't happy when being intervied after the game on Fox.

    He said he needs to make changes, and if players don't want to be here, they can **** off.

    We played well tonight but yet again, we cannot finish. So frustrating.

     

     

    Maybe the players are as confused as we are with CR and he is the one that should **** off. I mean..Kamau for Ibini..come on...

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    1 minute ago, Smoggy said:

    Maybe the players are as confused as we are with CR and he is the one that should **** off. I mean..Kamau for Ibini..come on...

    I said earlier that it should have been Duke off, not Kamau.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    And what was the point of bringing Muller on. He hardly touched the ball and couldn't be bothered running after it. The only spot he should have is on the next plane out of Oz!

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    27 minutes ago, redpanther61 said:

    And what was the point of bringing Muller on. He hardly touched the ball and couldn't be bothered running after it. The only spot he should have is on the next plane out of Oz!

    Desperation.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    56 minutes ago, Wanderboy said:

    Carl wasn't happy when being intervied after the game on Fox.

    He said he needs to make changes, and if players don't want to be here, they can **** off.

    We played well tonight but yet again, we cannot finish. So frustrating.

     

     

    Didn't he say that if players don't want to give their all HE (as in CR) doesn't want to be at the football club?

     

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    21 minutes ago, Wanderingbeersclub said:

    Didn't he say that if players don't want to give their all HE (as in CR) doesn't want to be at the football club?

    Robinson joined Oct 15. We then signed or extended:

    • Grozos promoted to senior squad
    • Lesiotis
    • Dorrans
    • Margush
    • Cancar
    • Kamau extension (technically his contract expired before he rejoined us)
    • Troisi
    • Gordon
    • Ibini
    • James the loan GK
    • Mutch
    • Duke
    • Wilmering promoted to senior squad
    • Russell contract extension
    • McDonald
    • Ugarkovic
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I think the rot started when he substituted Tass for Ziegler in that game against the Jets and CR's excuse has been that Tass had an ankle injury and we don't see Tass for 6 weeks.

    CR should be sacked, the supporters have lost faith in him and can see the BS right through him. He talks up a big game yet fails to deliver. This team with this depth and talent should have been a top 3 yet we're sitting in 9th and it won't be long to WU over take us if they can get their act together.

    As for JT and Lederer, they both need to review their operations and running of the club. It's **** shambolic

    Edited by SBW
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    It's the butterfly effect. 15 April 2018, Riera misses a penalty that would have given us the lead (and most likely the win needed to secure 6th place). This leads to Gombau being sacked. Imagine where we'd be now if that one kick went slightly differently...

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    3 hours ago, nick said:

    It's the butterfly effect. 15 April 2018, Riera misses a penalty that would have given us the lead (and most likely the win needed to secure 6th place). This leads to Gombau being sacked. Imagine where we'd be now if that one kick went slightly differently...

    Champions of Asia obviously, we only have to look at the extraordinary success gombau has had in India 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    7 hours ago, mack said:

    Robinson joined Oct 15. We then signed or extended:

    • Grozos promoted to senior squad
    • Lesiotis
    • Dorrans
    • Margush
    • Cancar
    • Kamau extension (technically his contract expired before he rejoined us)
    • Troisi
    • Gordon
    • Ibini
    • James the loan GK
    • Mutch
    • Duke
    • Wilmering promoted to senior squad
    • Russell contract extension
    • McDonald
    • Ugarkovic

    Jesus that’s quite a list. Hopefully at least half are going when JT fires Robbo

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    8 hours ago, Wanderingbeersclub said:

    Didn't he say that if players don't want to give their all HE (as in CR) doesn't want to be at the football club?

     

     

    I cannot believe he said that!! 

    See ya CR. You are not only a fraud, but you are a piece of ****. 

    He needs to be shown the door this morning. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites
    8 hours ago, Wanderingbeersclub said:

    Didn't he say that if players don't want to give their all HE (as in CR) doesn't want to be at the football club?

     

     

    No I think he said he doesn't want them to be here

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...