Jump to content
  • Perth Break Losing Streak With VAR Help


    mack

    The Video Assistant Referee system once again failed the Wanderers, as they finished 3-1 losers having played over 80 minutes with a man disadvantage.

    Keanu Baccus saw a straight red on a dubious VAR review in the 6th minute, Liam Reddy should have seen red 10 minutes later, however a brace to Diego Castro and a goal to Andy Keogh was enough to defeat the Wanderers who only managed one goal in return via Oriol Riera.

    The controversy started early out in Western Australia. After Brendan Hamill charged up field with the ball on the right wing, his poor cross allowed Perth to launch an immediate counter with a gaping hole in the Wanderers backline that Castro launched a through ball in behind.

    The near side linesman appeared to completely miss what was surely Joel Chianese in an offside position, and he ran through on goal only to fall to the turf upon the lightest of touches upon the shoulder from Baccus. After several agonising minutes of slow motion replays the decision was eventually made that there had been an "obvious" error. Baccus was promptly dismissed from the field. Castro took the resulting penalty and slotted it past Vedran Janjetovic. Fox Sports never bothered showing a wide angle to the VAR to determine the seemingly impossible job Chianese had made of staying onside, and didn't show one at half or full time either.

    10 minutes later Liam Reddy should have followed Baccus down the tunnel after he chopped down Oriol Riera with a very late studs up lunge that collected the marquee striker square on the knee. Instead the referee used a very lenient interpretation of the new law regarding "triple punishment" on fouls in the penalty area to only show the ex- Wanderers keeper a yellow. Riera did the same good job of the penalty as Castro did, but the signs for the Wanderers were not good as the travel, heat & playing a man down was taking a clear toll on their chances.

    Brendan Hamill compounded his error by barging down Chianese on the edge of the area in the 40th minute, well within Castro free kick range. The 2015/16 Johnny Warren Medal winner obliged the home fans request to shoot by arcing a stunning free kick over the wall and into the top corner from 20 yards out and past Janjetovic's late dive.

    Andy Keogh ended the game as a contest with an immediately 3rd goal. This time it was Thwaite caught out of position on the left wing, Castro was found in behind, and with Thwaite missing & Hamill doing little to trouble his markers, Castro laid the ball to Keogh and the striker blasted it past Janjetovic.

    Josep Gombau made a host of changes in the second half, the only real chance came with Marcelo Carrusca volleying a powerful shot into the base of the upright midway through the half, while Perth glided through to their first win in 6 games.


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    3 hours ago, FCB said:

    Depends what you consider "immediate success". We were competitive under Foxe, and turned to shite under Gombau. Foxe, with the support of one or two competent assistants, could have been our Muscat.

    You defend one incoming coach, and diminish the other. Foxe saw us win the first ever Rd1 game. Had it not been for Gillet we would have won the Allianz derby. Not bad for an assistant is his very first gig as head coach.

    Back in 2013/14 both VIC and Mariners lost their respective coaches early in the season, which can be compared with what we copped in October. The assistants took over, and the teams remained competitive, come 3rd and 4th. Much less can be said about Gombau.

     

    i still keep remembering that season. Gombau hitting the spoon position then reversing it all to come back and **** everyone. I have not yet lost hope.

    Link to comment
    2 hours ago, Jimspade said:

    i still keep remembering that season. Gombau hitting the spoon position then reversing it all to come back and **** everyone. I have not yet lost hope.

    I have....

    Link to comment
    3 hours ago, HillsPanther said:

    Also forgot to mention that Reddy had no intention of playing the ball. His only intention was to take out the player. Bozza never lets the facts get in the way of a good Fox story.

    Bozza got two faces.

    Link to comment
    5 hours ago, MartinTyler said:

    Earlier today on Twitter he said he was gong to pursue the offside angle.

     

    4 hours ago, btron3000 said:

    Yes they are very quiet on the offside.  Might it be because a) they don't have a good shot of it (which undermines their precious VAR) or b) they know that not being able to check for offside in this situation is just stupid (and undermines their precious VAR).

    We probably would have lost anyway  and it doesn't matter now but I need to know if it was offside . 

    Link to comment
    19 hours ago, MartinTyler said:

    Earlier today on Twitter he said he was gong to pursue the offside angle.

    He went through the footage but only showed what we've already seen, the camera shot that doesn't show Chianese when the ball was played.

    Link to comment
    21 hours ago, Jimspade said:

    i still keep remembering that season. Gombau hitting the spoon position then reversing it all to come back and **** everyone. I have not yet lost hope.

    That was Amor

    Link to comment



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



  • Posts

    • The guy is a professional footballer, even playing on a different side to his preferred, the concept of defending doesn’t change. He hardly looked like he was giving it a go. I think all too often we can be so lenient on mistakes made by players across the league. Let’s not forget that they are professionals, they get paid (a bloody decent amount) and should have the skillset required to atleast be able to do a job in a different to preferred position. It’s not like all age, where one week they are banging then in as a striker and then next they’ve got the gloves on as the regular keeper is away with the missus.  
    • More like Neverlosin' the way they're going.
×
×
  • Create New...