Jump to content
  • Same Old Wanderers Fall To Macarthur Debut Defeat


    mack

    The Western Sydney Wanderers began their 2020/21 A-League campaign hosting new side Macarthur FC, resulting in a lucky 1-0 win for the visitors after a Mark Milligan deflection from a free kick gave the Bulls all three points in their debut.

    Macarthur FC Bulls out of Campbelltown drove down the Hume Highway to take part in their first ever A-League match. The Wanderers new manager Carl Robinson picked a lineup including all of the major new signings for the champions of Asia, with James Troisi, Graham Dorrans, Bernie Ibini, Daniel Margush and Ziggy Gordon joining returning players Tass Mourdoukoutas, Daniel Georgievski, Tate Russell, Keanu Baccus, Simon Cox and newly appointed club Captain Dylan McGowan.

    The opening stages were a flurry of activity with little end result, until the officials and the VAR made their introduction with the awarding of a clear handball against Jovanovic after the defender reacted poorly to a long shot from Dorrans, and moved his arms from his side into the path of the ball. The referee after spending 5 minutes reviewing slow motion replays elected to overturn his correct decision and cancel the penalty.

    Simon Cox was later booked after tripping over his feet in the Macarthur penalty area, as it to emphasis yet again that the referees will be looking for any excuse to punish the Wanderers. New season, same old referees in the A-League. Macarthur dominated most of the half, with multiple chances falling to Wanderers youth product Moudi Najjar.

    Tate Russell had one of the better chances after cutting inside onto his left before firing into the hands of Adam Federici at the near post of the Macarthur goal. Russell sprug into life again with a burst down the sideline, his cutback found Cox and the marquee striker hammered it high but straight and Federici tipped it over. From the resulting corner the ball fell to Ibini, he was on the back foot and his strike lacked direction.

    The two sides traded shots on target in the first minutes of the second half, Troisi brought out the best from Federici in order to stop his sliding shot.

    Macarthur thought they had their first A-League goal, James Meredith sliced through the Wanderers defence before sliding the ball across the 6 yard box for an unmarked Rose to tap in from a few yards out, only to be denied by a very tight, but accurate, offside flag. Federici was called into action again in the 55th minute, after Macarthur blocked a Dorrans shot that fell to Baccus the young midfielder fired towards the top corner and the Bulls custodian leapt into the air to keep it out. It was followed up by a mammoth goal-line scramble with Troisi, Mourdoukoutas, Ibini all getting touches but Gordon couldn't find an angle to shoot. Daniel Margush saved a mirror effort of Cox's shot from the first half, this time coming from Bulls substitute Benat.

    Keanu Baccus gave away what became a fatal free kick in the 71st minute. His slight clip of Hollman invited the ref to hand Macarthur a free kick slightly off-centre and 24 yards out from goal. He fired towards the far post before a massive deflection diverted the ball past a Margush desperate lunge to give the visitor's their first goal in a competitive fixture.

    As the game entered stoppage time Mark Milligan tried to chip Margush from beyond halfway but lacked the power to fly over the head of the keeper. Kwame Yeboah got lucky as a Macarthur tackle knocked the ball into his path, with a couple of strides into the area he shot toward the near post but Federici's outstretched hand blocked it well.

    Ultimately the Wanderers did the same thing they've done for years now, fail to gel with their passing combinations, lacked quality in the final third and ran around like headless chickens for no reward. It's not the start Carl Robinson would have asked for, and keeps the Wanderers in last place with fellow first round losers Brisbane Roar.

    The Wanderers next match is scheduled for Friday the 8th of January 2021 against Newcastle Jets in Newcastle.


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Dorrans is a different player to Schweg, looks better with the ball at his feet despite a few little **** ups he mostly fixed himself.

    Federici had a great game to avoid 2-1 maybe 3-1 scoreline. 
     

    If you go from the back;

    We have no idea with Margush but decent enough early signed

     

    a back three of Ziggy, McGowan and Tass seems to be improvement on last season. Ziggy was great tonight.

    Midfield looks messy with no clear roles. I’m not sure if that’s by design. Dorrans will finds his feet. He’s been ill and confined all preseason.

    Front line is without doubt improved as a whole but Cox still weighs us down heavily (pun intended) and we are missing Duke.

    Aquilina was a standout in his short time. He should see off Georgie in no time if he continues that performance.

     

     

    Link to comment

    first half we showed nothing and got dominated and despite losing in the 2nd half(a very wanderers thing to do) the 2nd half was much better, at least we got closer to actually scoring goals in the 2nd half

    Link to comment
    1 hour ago, Wanderingbeersclub said:

    Don't get all the negativity around Dorrans. Thought he did well. Especially when you consider he only got out of a months worth of quarantine 5 mins ago after testing positive. 

    Overall I think we look better than last year and will only improve. 

    Bit of a worry up top but Bernie looked like a player who has refused to train for 6 weeks. He will come good. 

    Too early to start removing your shoelaces ladies and gents. We will be ok.

     

    Aquilina looked a player too.

    Glass half full over here.

    You guys should be better at losing by now...what with all the practice we have had.

     

    Post of the night.  Well said Sir!

    Link to comment
    2 hours ago, Unlimited said:

    Federici is a top goalkeeper and saved them, literally and figuratively, big time.

    Great analysis, Unlimited.

    And I think the fact that Federici gained so much praise for his performance also does indicate that he had to make some impressive saves- which meant our team did put him under pressure at times.

    Link to comment
    20 minutes ago, wendybr said:

    Great analysis, Unlimited.

    And I think the fact that Federici gained so much praise for his performance also does indicate that he had to make some impressive saves- which meant our team did put him under pressure at times.

    I think I watched a different game, we didn’t give him that much to do.

    Link to comment
    4 hours ago, mack said:

    I think he made one really good save off Baccus. Everything else was pretty routine for an A-League level keeper.

    Cox drilled one straight at him that looked spectacular, but you expect it to be saved. Yes the Baccus one was good.

    Link to comment
    6 hours ago, StringerBellend said:

    I think I watched a different game, we didn’t give him that much to do.

    Your game watching experience was clearly colored by your beloved Yeboah coming on and doing a Yeboah :-)

    Magush was forced to make one save throughout the game, Federici a few more, and he made a difference.

    No, it wasn't a great display of football, and I am not sure what people were expecting. Troisi, Ibini, Dorrans arrived at the club 10 days ago or so, of course they are looking rusty. Also, it's easy to be critical of Cox, playing against the great wall of Serbia would not have been much fun.

    The Bulls will be a handful, yet ultimately WSW were beaten by a deflected free kick that wasn't one, on a different day WSW will win the game.

     

    Link to comment
    13 minutes ago, FCB said:

    Your game watching experience was clearly colored by your beloved Yeboah coming on and doing a Yeboah :-)

    Magush was forced to make one save throughout the game, Federici a few more, and he made a difference.

    No, it wasn't a great display of football, and I am not sure what people were expecting. Troisi, Ibini, Dorrans arrived at the club 10 days ago or so, of course they are looking rusty. Also, it's easy to be critical of Cox, playing against the great wall of Serbia would not have been much fun.

    The Bulls will be a handful, yet ultimately WSW were beaten by a deflected free kick that wasn't one, on a different day WSW will win the game.

     

    Yeah, I'm okay with the result. Would prefer to have won but we're still being stitched together so we're not a finished product yet. Also that defender on Cox was touching him so often he should have bought him dinner. There was a fair few holding back of players and shirt pulling incidents perpetrated by Macarthur that went unpunished by that ref. IMO.

    Its early days,  I'm cautiously optimistic. Let's see in another 4-5 games. Maybe I'll join the Doom n Gloom squad then. We will see.

    Link to comment

    To be honest it wasn't a bad general performance from the team we had moments but we really need a striker. We have not replaced Duke and from what I saw if Carl wants to play Cox up front on his own we are in trouble completely marked out of the game. We need more from Troisi qnd Ibini it just was not enough and sluggish. Especially Ibini geez the guy has a touch that made Majok look like Maradona and lazy in defence. Would prefer Muller of Ibini is gonna give that kind of performance

    Link to comment
    10 minutes ago, EmMac said:

    Yeah, I'm okay with the result. Would prefer to have won but we're still being stitched together so we're not a finished product yet. Also that defender on Cox was touching him so often he should have bought him dinner. There was a fair few holding back of players and shirt pulling incidents perpetrated by Macarthur that went unpunished by that ref. IMO.

    Its early days,  I'm cautiously optimistic. Let's see in another 4-5 games. Maybe I'll join the Doom n Gloom squad then. We will see.

    I don't think it's a doom and gloom squad but more that folks are extremely frustrated with how we have been playing over the past three seasons at least. A new manager comes in and promises things will change then comes the time to walk the walk and we find out we're playing on crutches.

    There were some good signs against Macarthur, but we really do need to win games or we end up chasing our own tails.....again. 

    We need a gun striker with pace.

    Edited by sonar
    Link to comment
    6 hours ago, mack said:

    I think he made one really good save off Baccus. Everything else was pretty routine for an A-League level keeper.

    You say that but week in week out we see simple stuff hit the back of the net. Feds is a clear standout. Lesser keepers will make mistakes in those positions.

    Even if we say only 1 was a real stunner, we forced 4 saves out of Feds. Margush was bested by Milligan’s arse. Other than that there was no threat on goal, though mostly because Najjar couldn’t head a ball to save his life

    Link to comment

    Our last three seasons.....( not including 20/21 )

    Games 80

    Won   23

    Drawn   21

    Lost   36

     

    Was there any interviews by the manager after the game last night....?

    Edited by sonar
    Link to comment
    7 hours ago, mack said:

    I think he made one really good save off Baccus. Everything else was pretty routine for an A-League level keeper.

    This

    our nability to score was on us, we either didn’t take the shot, hit it straight at him (Cox) or tripped over are own feet (yeboah) 

    We will struggle without a proper striker 

     

    Link to comment
    15 minutes ago, sonar said:

    Our last three seasons.....( not including 20/21 )

    Games 80

    Won   23

    Drawn   21

    Lost   36

     

    Was there any interviews by the manager after the game last night....?

    Yes there was.....he thinks the freekick was not a freekick and we were unlucky with the deflection. He also knew some players were underdone as they haven't played for a long time.

    Link to comment
    1 minute ago, tardotz said:

    Yes there was.....he thinks the freekick was not a freekick and we were unlucky with the deflection. He also knew some players were underdone as they haven't played for a long time.

    :good:

    Thanks.

    It showed we were underdone. Things can only get better. ( I hope )

    Edited by sonar
    Link to comment

     Looks like the VAR this season is going to be a bigger problem than before. For our penalty, I cannot see how anyone can decide for or against with those two camera angles. Not sure if this was part of the cost cutting but how you can overturn a decision when it's not clear on camera its ridiculous. When inconclusive they should always go with the initial refs call.

    Link to comment
    1 minute ago, tardotz said:

     Looks like the VAR this season is going to be a bigger problem than before. For our penalty, I cannot see how anyone can decide for or against with those two camera angles. Not sure if this was part of the cost cutting but how you can overturn a decision when it's not clear on camera its ridiculous. When inconclusive they should always go with the initial refs call.

    Georgeivski last season bought his hands to his chest as protection and got penalized............last night the Macarthur player wasn't. Inconsistency in rule interpretation. 

    Link to comment

    I'm not going to join the doom and gloom merchants just yet (and there are far more on FB than here!!) as there were certainly encouraging signs even though the Bulls were marginally better on the night. We had some decent passages of play at times, something not really seen last season even when we were winning at the start.

    Must admit I didn't expect Dorrans or Ibini to start as they have not had the best of pre-season build ups but maybe the boss decided to take that risk. Both were disappointing but I'm fairly confident that we will see better from them as the season progresses. Baccus didn't start that well but grew as the game went on as it appeared that he had more work to do as Dorrans wasn't really effective. Tate Russell was probably our best and I did read that he had a minor injury when he was subbed. Biggest worry for me was Cox; I really want him to do well and he certainly looks fitter but he still appears to lumber around for most of the game. No other real shockers but our formation did lead to the Bulls having too much space at times.

    Link to comment
    2 minutes ago, xposedPatricK said:

     

    Everytime Murgash had a goal kick, fox would show a reply then when it was back live, Macarthur would have possession. 

    I noticed that, particularly in the second half....there was one instance when they were too busy showing Muller's new hair style/colour. Fox's coverage is going to be that much more painful this season without Simon Hill.

    Link to comment
    44 minutes ago, sonar said:

    Was there any interviews by the manager after the game last night....?

    Yes - https://www.a-league.com.au/video/robinson-xxx-press-conference-a-league

     

    59 minutes ago, Upthehill said:

    You say that but week in week out we see simple stuff hit the back of the net. Feds is a clear standout. Lesser keepers will make mistakes in those positions.

    Yep, a lesser keeper would have been beaten by Yeboah's late attempt. We downplay solid GK performances, and at the same time bitch about substandard HAL stuff. Federici will be the Bulls' Lopar.

     

    20 minutes ago, StringerBellend said:

    As negative as I am right now, I think we will be ok this season

    Looking forward to your positivity emerging, especially should we enter another lock down.

    Link to comment



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...