Jump to content
  • Gombau Sacked By Wanderers


    mack

    Failing to finish in the finals has proven fatal for Josep Gombau as the Spanish coach was sacked by the Western Sydney Wanderers this morning.

    After just 5 months and 13 days since his first game in charge, having been appointed in the wake of Tony Popovic's shock abandonment of the club a week before the season start, the Wanderers board elected to punt the charismatic Spaniard out of a job that he had been given a 3 year contract for. Gombau's tenure was dogged by pundits both in print & television hounding every move he made, with every substitution met with cries of player feuds and his best unbeaten run of games of 4 games between January 1st and January 13 was not enough to keep the wolves at bay.

    Gombau had to take charge of an ill-disciplined, unfit and woefully under-performing playing squad and his attempt to rebuild the team in his Catalan image was met with indifference, apathy or hostility from many in the the playing group. Hayden Foxe managing a 5 game unbeaten start to season papered over the cracks as he and Popovic before his exit saw a clear reliance on marquee Oriol Riera to save the team from embarrassment against Wellington & Blacktown City in the FFA Cup, while in the A-League the team were incapable of closing out matches strongly to hold onto wins, even against the Central Coast Mariners or teams playing a man down.

    If the earliest results were less than inspiring, the 5-0 annihilation in the second Sydney Derby of the season drove home that the Gombau era would not be smooth sailing to begin with, or even that he would "get the best" out of an attack as penetrative as a tennis ball thrown against a brick wall, and a defence that had more holes in it than swiss cheese. A 4-0 loss not long after to Newcastle saw urgent meetings take place amongst the club officials & staff, and a desire to transition more slowly to Gombau's intended tactics appeared to pay dividends, as the team picked up wins against Melbourne City and Brisbane Roar.

    That was unfortunately the peak of the Wanderers season, with back to back losses against Melbourne Victory & Perth Glory putting the side in danger of missing the finals series. A 3-0 win against Brisbane in the penultimate game of the regular season saw everything to play for against Gombau's former club Adelaide United, and yet they capitulated in a dismal 3-2 defeat, as Riera missed a penalty to bring the game level, and Keanu Baccus was sent off to kill his team's chances of playing in the finals.

    Rumours of squad infighting that rose to multiple fights between team-mates, poor off-field behaviour that saw Chris Herd banished from the side, the exits of Hayden Foxe & Robbie Cornthwaite after a training ground argument along with the whisper campaign in the media all resulted in Gombau losing full control over his team, and despite sections of the Wanderers supporter base wanting the club to see through the Gombau project, those who wanted a fresh direction have seen their hopes realised. The Wanderers board lost their patience with the "project manager", and Gombau was punted on Thursday morning.

    What direction the board go in remains to be seen. Original target Ante Milicic may be looking for a job after Graham Arnold takes over the Australian national team post-world cup, while German manager Dirk Schuster may be available in the next few weeks should his side Darmstadt 98 be relegated from Bundesliga 2.

    Ultimately, this season was a complete waste of time & money, and the blame lies squarely on the shoulders of John Tsatsimas and the ownership group fronted by Paul Lederer. Why on earth would any management team elect to bring in Gombau, a man who it was absolutely crystal clear would need time to implement his own style and bring in players that suited it, and then turn around and sack him 5 months later is inexplicable to me. If they really wanted to keep playing the same plodding, non-attacking style that Popovic had perfected before his exit, they should have told Popovic that it was too late to release him, or then let Foxe takeover until the end of this year.

    Instead, the Board effectively stole the time & money of every single season ticket holder, to watch a club held together on the pitch by Riera & Janjetovic while those in between failed to provide the remotest sense of application and skill unless they were facing the very worst teams in the competition. And for what? The new manager is going to come into a club in crisis, another dozen squad positions to fill, and the sense that having sacked their last manager within 6 months that it could happen again before Christmas.

    Good luck to whoever that is. You're going to need it.

    Edited by mack


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    4 minutes ago, GoatyMcGoatFace said:

    i would say we get rid of all 3 if we have to get rid of gombau, no player is bigger than the club and there are a lot of players who think they are not replaceable(santa i am looking at you, i hope you are looking at the door)

    Don't agree with you about Santalab,Goat. He put in. Gombau was in a no win situation from the get go. Feel sorry for the guy, who regardless of what has been said about him appears to be a decent human being.

    Link to comment
    1 minute ago, Jukes01 said:

    Yes this is no biggie, its a little bit different though if the manager starts being undermined by staff or players. 

    It cuts both ways though. A 'crisis' situation is a great opportunity for a leader to earn respect, it seems Gombau wasn't able to do that but instead lost respect. 

    While a 'manager' should be respected, realistically it needs to be earned, Gombau failed big time and it fell apart, he had to go to be fair. 

    Link to comment
    1 minute ago, matty said:

    It cuts both ways though. A 'crisis' situation is a great opportunity for a leader to earn respect, it seems Gombau wasn't able to do that but instead lost respect. 

    While a 'manager' should be respected, realistically it needs to be earned, Gombau failed big time and it fell apart, he had to go to be fair. 

    If the players didn't like what he was doing then there is no way he was going to get their respect no matter what he did. 

    Link to comment
    4 minutes ago, mack said:

    Let's not risk another fall out, how about we just make Riera the coach. Let him deal with it. If Frank Farina could be Player/Manager back in the day for Marconi I'm sure Riera can do it.

    agreed Riera is obviously a special little princess and we wouldnt want anyone making him upset or he might have a tantrum again

     

     

    4 minutes ago, sonar said:

    Don't agree with you about Santalab,Goat. He put in. Gombau was in a no win situation from the get go. Feel sorry for the guy, who regardless of what has been said about him appears to be a decent human being.

    honestly i appreciate what santa has done but lets be honest he is way past his best and he put his own interests above that of the club, you can save 242 people's lives but the moment you kill one person the police start coming after you......

    Link to comment
    Just now, sonar said:

    If the players didn't like what he was doing then there is no way he was going to get their respect no matter what he did. 

    You beat me to it. From what I remember the players didn't give him much of a chance and this occurred right from the moment he walked into the club. Not an easy situation for anyone because a lot of the players were brought out because Popovic convinced them of the way he was going to play. As a player you wouldn't feel so great when a new manager comes in and your whole season is thrown upside down with a different way of playing. I am not blaming Gombau or the players but I am not sure what Gombau could have done. The unrest started at the beginning with players like Cejudo who was benched, Cornthwaite also had a spell, same as Riera. It is what is but you are right it is a two way street and as a manager it would have been hard for Gombau to respect the players who were not willing to listen to him or give him a chance. 

     

     

    Link to comment
    1 hour ago, GoatyMcGoatFace said:

    i would say we get rid of all 3 if we have to get rid of gombau, no player is bigger than the club and there are a lot of players who think they are not replaceable(santa i am looking at you, i hope you are looking at the door)

    I don't think Santa said anything that wasn't obvious or true..  he also tried his best on the field (the little time he was allowed to play)and only spoke after the season was over.

    Is he past his best?..... probably but still bleeds red and black.

    Link to comment
    1 hour ago, hughsey said:

    Make of the following as you will. I was told this by an insider I know who works within the club:

    - JT and Josep had a falling out

    - Josep made an ultimatum that it was either he or Riera

    This sounds like the actions of a man who is trying to get fired.

    Link to comment
    7 minutes ago, lloydy136 said:

    This sounds like the actions of a man who is trying to get fired.

    Really. It sounds like a man who wanted to know where he stood. 

    Link to comment

    I didnt think the club would have the kahoonas to do this and i give them credit. They obviously realised they had the wrong man and made an early call one week after seasons end so the players and fans know ratjer than speculate for another month or so.

    I cant see them going for Okon risking another gombau philosophy season. 

    Interesting times but given this is football none of us should be surprised. At least the off season wont be a total bore.

    Link to comment
    30 minutes ago, Jukes01 said:

    Really. It sounds like a man who wanted to know where he stood. 

    Maybe, but If this is true, he went the wrong way about it. 

    Terrible leadership 

    Link to comment
    33 minutes ago, leslie said:

    I didnt think the club would have the kahoonas to do this and i give them credit. They obviously realised they had the wrong man and made an early call one week after seasons end so the players and fans know ratjer than speculate for another month or so.

    I cant see them going for Okon risking another gombau philosophy season. 

    Interesting times but given this is football none of us should be surprised. At least the off season wont be a total bore.

    Fair enough. My personal opinion is the club made a mistake, especially since they knew what they were getting into. None of this should have been a surprise to the Wanderers.

    Now that it's done, it would be interesting to see who they appoint. Let's hope a "mistake" is not compounded by more mistakes or a bigger mistake.

    For what it's worth I wasn't enamoured with the Gombau style. However I could definitely see we were improving especially in the last 3 games. We might have lost but that was mostly down to bad refereeing decisions and Ill discipline from the players.

    I honestly feel that Gombau deserved one more year especially considering how the Popovic saga unfolded and the player unrest he had to contend with. There are no excuses now, but I hope this time the club makes the decision and commits fully to the coach.

    My guess is the club will hire the dud Okon, then the club will truly get what they deserve. Watch this space.

    Edited by Jukes01
    Link to comment
    4 hours ago, mack said:

    There's not much point continuing this argument. The board clowns gave Gombau a 3 year deal and the impression that this season would be the foundation he built the next two on. And then sacked him 5 months later

    Yeah. I never thought he was going to get the boot, purely because letting your captain walk and moving your visa winger on without replacement for either are the actions of a man who has multiple years to implement his vision. So as late as January Josep must have thought he was here for multiple years.

    Link to comment
    1 hour ago, leslie said:

    I didnt think the club would have the kahoonas to do this and i give them credit. They obviously realised they had the wrong man and made an early call one week after seasons end

    Agree. No matter what led to us being in this situation, I admire them for making a decisive call, provided that call was indeed made because of what they saw behind the scenes was not what they wanted to see from a manager, and hopefully not because some whiney players or fans didn't want him around. The last thing you want is clueless clowns with no football understanding making decisions because of the complaints of others. 

    Link to comment
    3 hours ago, btron3000 said:

    Agree. No matter what led to us being in this situation, I admire them for making a decisive call, provided that call was indeed made because of what they saw behind the scenes was not what they wanted to see from a manager, and hopefully not because some whiney players or fans didn't want him around. The last thing you want is clueless clowns with no football understanding making decisions because of the complaints of others. 

    If you listen to The Fox Football Podcast, Adam Peacock hosted the Wanderers Medal night where Riera picked up all the awards and said it was a weird night. Pretty sure that I heard that there was a distinct separation between Gombau and most of the players. I still maintain that Gombau doesn't get Western Sydney and the place our club sits.

    So far 3 out of the four bottom 4 coaches are no longer in a job, only Kenny Lowe left.

    Link to comment
    20 hours ago, FCWanderers said:

    Gombau fell out with a number of players and has left others unconvinced he has the ability to lead a title challenge next year.

    Club officials had also become alarmed at a noticeable decline in the squad’s fitness since Gombau’s appointment.

    https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/football/a-league/teams/western-sydney/western-sydney-wanderers-have-sacked-coach-josep-gombau/news-story/500561c7be35fab8c7e0114ad2393455

    What was going on with the squads fitness this year and their ability to run out the back end of games.

     

    Makes for interesting reading. Beyond the Gombau files:

    • Fitzgerald, Tongyink, Elrich, and Kamau appear to be done deal.
    • New coach is supposed to come from Germany.
    • Raul has an option for another year.

    Also, coaching support staff is going to be refreshed. All traces of Popa and Gombau will be gone.

     

    And then there's Bossi

    https://www.smh.com.au/sport/soccer/never-say-never-say-wanderers-but-now-is-too-soon-for-popa-return-20180419-p4zalp.html

     

     

     

    Link to comment
    1 hour ago, Paul01 said:

    If you listen to The Fox Football Podcast, Adam Peacock hosted the Wanderers Medal night where Riera picked up all the awards and said it was a weird night. Pretty sure that I heard that there was a distinct separation between Gombau and most of the players. I still maintain that Gombau doesn't get Western Sydney and the place our club sits.

    So far 3 out of the four bottom 4 coaches are no longer in a job, only Kenny Lowe left.

    A) Kenny is hanging out for Borneo or where ever the **** they want to play

    B) Its hard enough to get anyone to come to WA in the first place. 

    Link to comment

    @btron3000 

    you say the foreigners were rubbish?

    so let me ask did you think roly and cejudo were rubbish when we signed them - these guys had well credentialed careers to date roly being a player we spoke about for years on forum trying to sign 

    For you and others who say they are crap which is a fair statement given what they showed - how come if generally people thought they were good when we signed them now when josep failed to get anything out of them it’s nothing to do with him 

    noone put a gun to Gombau’s head and said take the job - if the club said to him the season is a write off fair enough but if they said you need to perform than he was right to be sacked 

    all the talk of player unrest - it’s his job to manage it and looks as though he failed miserably 

    he cant be given a free ride merely because he came in after pre season!!!

    Link to comment
    3 hours ago, Paul01 said:

    If you listen to The Fox Football Podcast, Adam Peacock hosted the Wanderers Medal night where Riera picked up all the awards and said it was a weird night. Pretty sure that I heard that there was a distinct separation between Gombau and most of the players. I still maintain that Gombau doesn't get Western Sydney and the place our club sits.

    So far 3 out of the four bottom 4 coaches are no longer in a job, only Kenny Lowe left.

    The DT suggests that Gombau was not on the same table as JT and Lederer (unlike Popa in previous years), that he was not mentioned in any of the speeches, was not involved with any of the award presentations, and that of the players only Carrusca was seen having a proper conversation with him. Poor bastard (Gombau, not Carrusca).

    No wonder Gombau wanted to have more than a dozen players replaced with guys he's previously worked with (according to Smitthies, admittingly). Western Sydney Reds/United: how much fun would that have been?

    Link to comment

    Do we assume that making the finals was a KPI agreed to by Josep. If so then the club has every right to terminate based on performance. If not, do we assume he's to be paid out his remaining 2 years, inturn putting more financial stress on the club? Sounds not only like a bad selection but also a bad business decision.

    Link to comment
    Just now, ZachMercer said:

    Do we assume that making the finals was a KPI agreed to by Josep. If so then the club has every right to terminate based on performance. If not, do we assume he's to be paid out his remaining 2 years, inturn putting more financial stress on the club? Sounds not only like a bad selection but also a bad business decision.

    If it was something agreed to in the contract then no, they wouldn't have paid him out. 

    I am still fearing we are going to get Okon, that would be my worst nightmare. From the youth set up in Australia to the Mariners in the A-league he has been an utter failure. The guy can't coach. 

    Link to comment
    4 minutes ago, Jukes01 said:

    If it was something agreed to in the contract then no, they wouldn't have paid him out. 

    I am still fearing we are going to get Okon, that would be my worst nightmare. From the youth set up in Australia to the Mariners in the A-league he has been an utter failure. The guy can't coach. 

    Have to agree mate. Okon = Coffin Nail.

    Link to comment
    8 hours ago, Jukes01 said:

    Fair enough. My personal opinion is the club made a mistake, especially since they knew what they were getting into. None of this should have been a surprise to the Wanderers.

    Now that it's done, it would be interesting to see who they appoint. Let's hope a "mistake" is not compounded by more mistakes or a bigger mistake.

    For what it's worth I wasn't enamoured with the Gombau style. However I could definitely see we were improving especially in the last 3 games. We might have lost but that was mostly down to bad refereeing decisions and Ill discipline from the players.

    I honestly feel that Gombau deserved one more year especially considering how the Popovic saga unfolded and the player unrest he had to contend with. There are no excuses now, but I hope this time the club makes the decision and commits fully to the coach.

    My guess is the club will hire the dud Okon, then the club will truly get what they deserve. Watch this space.

    What last three games did you watch? The last game was a shambles, as was the victory loss (promising 20 mins aside) 

    Sure they were an improvement from the city away but that’s a pretty low bar to set.

    on the players falling out if it was one or two players then yes blame players. This has been pretty much every senior player (and that’s just the ones we know about). There is a deeper problem there than one player being a tit

    Also club backed gombau in Jan, they released cornthwaite who was pissed off, they let foxe go too. But the issues kept coming. The final straw would have been Santalab. 

    Link to comment

    Carly Adno on FNR this morning said that she was at the Wanderers Awards Night and noticed that Gombau had little to no interaction with any players other than Carrusca and he wasn't even seated at the Chairman's table like Popa was other years. Seems like it had already been decided at that time.

    Link to comment
    6 minutes ago, Zakman said:

    Carly Adno on FNR this morning said that she was at the Wanderers Awards Night and noticed that Gombau had little to no interaction with any players other than Carrusca and he wasn't even seated at the Chairman's table like Popa was other years. Seems like it had already been decided at that time.

    It’s pretty sad isn’t it, if that’s the case then it’s poor form by the club. It didn’t work out but the guy should be treated well

    Link to comment
    10 minutes ago, MathyouWSW said:

    Personally, I still feel that Hayden Foxe should of been given the role and not Gombau in the first place.

    For what reason? Foxe was your typical 'temporary coach' and the team didn't reach any great heights (apart from 1st half v Perth) during his tenure culminating in a woeful show against 10-man Victory and FFA Cup defeat at the hands of Adelaide.

    Link to comment



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...