Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


 Content Type 



News Articles

Western Sydney Wanderers Youth Match Reports

Western Sydney Wanderers Match Database

Western Sydney Wanderers Women Match Reports

Western Sydney Wanderers Player Database

Western Sydney Wanderers NPL



Everything posted by Edinburgh

  1. Getting used a lot is okay, nothing to get used to. But if that results in sub standard pitches for us then we shouldn't just get used to it. As a major tenant, we should complain loud and long. Hopefully the super duper new pitch is up to it and we'll have nothing to complain about.
  2. Edinburgh

    Off Topic Thread 4

    Neither/None. Ask Smoggy for a sketch instead.
  3. Edinburgh

    HAL 2018/19 Round 22

    Both teams encroached, multiple players on each team. Georgevski was almost alone on the right where he was, there were several others on the left, including a couple ahead of Georgevski. So, your last paragraph situation did occur. I don't know the rules, and how they are applied, well enough, but to me denying the goal was correct (as I think everyone agrees). The problem/question then is which team is favoured by the next decision. With both teams encroaching significantly neither of the teams clearly merit a favourable decision. Unfortunately, maintaining the status quo of retaking the penalty does favour the attacking team. Maybe that's the best result, given they earned a penalty?
  4. Edinburgh


    But I want to eat NOW!
  5. Edinburgh

    HAL 2018/19 Round 22

    The problem is where we are leading to!
  6. I think he has been okay injury wise until getting injured in a national squad at the start of this season. Since then very unfortunate. I don't know what his injuries have been or whether they are all related to the first one. Hopefully he can recover fully in the off season.
  7. Just to be sure, you might need to add some punctuation
  8. Edinburgh

    Central Coast Mariners: Season 2018/19

    Not the first one this season
  9. Edinburgh

    Central Coast Mariners: Season 2018/19

    Penalty saved in time added, but scored from save, denied by var due to encroachment retaken saved again!!!! FT 100th minute. 2-3
  10. Edinburgh

    Central Coast Mariners: Season 2018/19

    Mariners leading 0-3 against Jets 70 minutes in
  11. Edinburgh

    A-League Expansion Thread V3

    Pretty damning! Why am I not surprised? On the SWS introduction being delayed to suit WSW, at the member committee meeting JT strongly stated WSW made no such request.
  12. Edinburgh

    Off Topic Thread 4

    A clip posted on the music thread today is Peace Train by Cat Stevens. I enjoyed listening and watching but it was all tinged by the sadness of thinking all through it that the coming together for peace that is sung about in the song is instead coming apart these days, aided by the ....... nah, I'll leave out the next bit.
  13. Edinburgh

    What Really Grinds My Gears 5

    Rude callers on the phone. I just received another call from the "telephone department". Telling me they had just put my number on the list to deal with scam calls and the like. I said "like yours" and she said "no sir" and hung up! How rude!
  14. Edinburgh

    Jaushua Sotirio

    Wasn't he injured after his last game and so was unavailable for a week or two!? And now, after more good results, he has to make his way back into the match squad.
  15. Edinburgh

    WSW Merchandise 2017/18

    Relax Manfred, it wouldn't look as good on you! Or me!!!!
  16. Edinburgh

    Sydney FC: Season 2018/19

    I can sense your disappointment
  17. I'm afraid I don't know what any of you are saying. You're comments are ambiguous to me. - overblown as evidence of what? - well you aren't what? - stand by what? - too much is made of what?
  18. Wendy, another very interesting discussion. I'm glad my child raising years were several years ago.
  19. A very interesting discussion, as Wendy said, and enlightening as well. It certainly helped me understand why the balanced opinions that I seek are rarely expressed these days. It's a pity that there is little or no expectation that such understanding will be reciprocated. I haven't seen much of JP but the little I have seen he was always up against one or more people who clearly had an agenda against him** and rarely, no never, allowed him to finish what he was trying to say and explain. I wonder if he would sound more reasonable to his doubters if he was given the non judgemental freedom that this interviewer allowed. ** That is, introduced/forced their own political, philosophical and religious stances into the debate.